Posted by naomikritzer
https://naomikritzer.com/2025/09/18/election-2025-minneapolis-mayoral-race-the-four-contenders/
http://naomikritzer.com/?p=24148
There are fifteen people running for Minneapolis mayor. You only have to worry about four of them, and this post will talk about those four. If you want to know more about all the others, that is in a separate post.
The four candidates who might actually win in November:
Jacob Frey (incumbent)
Omar Fateh
Jazz Hampton
DeWayne Davis
The tl;dr is that my current ranking is (1) DeWayne Davis; (2) Omar Fateh; (3) Jazz Hampton. What I would really strongly encourage people to do if they don’t want Jacob but aren’t sure how they feel about the precise order of the challengers is to pick a favorite as soon as possible and donate and doorknock. Four years ago, I got my post up really late, and I was indecisive, and I think I was probably not the only person who got caught up in analysis paralysis. Analysis paralysis that keeps you from donating and volunteering will get you four more years of Jacob Frey! I am here RIGHT NOW, TODAY with information to help you make a decision (which can totally be different from the one I’m making! Get out there and doorknock for Omar Fateh or Jazz Hampton if one of them is your first choice!) Frey is extremely unpopular; the biggest hill to climb for his opponents is name recognition.
I made an effort this month to meet DeWayne Davis, Omar Fateh, and Jazz Hampton in person. I went to a DeWayne Davis meet-and-greet at a park, an Omar Fateh fundraiser, and a Jazz Hampton meet-and-greet at a playground. I asked each of them if they could identify a problem that they thought they could solve as mayor — Minneapolis is facing plenty of problems, some very complicated and some more straightforward, was there any particular problem that they looked at and thought, “make me mayor, and I could fix this one.” I didn’t try to find Jacob to ask this question because he’s been mayor for eight years; he’s had his chance.
Something I found worthwhile was the Mayoral Candidate Q&A from the city DFL convention. There are some challenging and interesting questions. (You can skip 5 seconds at a time with arrow keys if there are candidates you don’t want to hear from.) One caveat is that the video was taken from over to the side and you can’t always tell who’s talking; you have to be able to recognize the candidate’s voices (which mostly I can, but mileage may vary here.)
Cut because the analysis is going to get long!
Jacob Frey (incumbent)
Jacob Frey is a deeply performative empty suit who literally runs away from hard questions. He’s also genuinely terrible at working with the City Council, terrible at collective problem solving, and terrible at overseeing the Minneapolis police.
To give him the credit I think is due: back in 2017 I remember someone who was ranking him second because they thought he’d build a lot of housing, and Minneapolis has added a lot of housing in the last eight years, both affordable and market rate, and the result is that while no one here feels like housing is particularly affordable, we’re doing better than most blue-state cities. I don’t know that Frey deserves a ton of credit for this but he has at least avoided screwing it up.
Two of the biggest ongoing issues in the city are homelessness and policing, and on both he has been consistently performative, ineffective, and cowardly in the sense of being unwilling to tackle hard questions.
- The biggest crisis Frey has faced while mayor was the murder of George Floyd and the civil unrest that followed. Outgoing mayor Betsy Hodges had actually written up a handbook on how to handle something like this, which Frey ignored. The after-action review is scathing: “Interviewees stated minimal direction came from the Mayor’s Office, OEM and other city departments during the unrest. Specifically, some felt that the Mayor’s Office showed no leadership and was ‘rudderless.’ Some indicated that the Mayor, Governor and MPD Chief were notably absent when people felt they should have been present. Many mentioned that the Mayor seemed unprepared but that he was ‘doing his best.'”
- Frey has routinely lied about the number of unsheltered people in Minneapolis and the availability of shelter beds. He will insist that shelter beds are available when this is absolutely not true.
- Frey claimed in 2021 to have banned no-knock warrants. In 2022, Amir Locke was killed ten seconds into a police raid made with a no-knock warrant (for no good reason). If you want your blood pressure to go up you can read this interview Frey did with MPR where he talks about how “the communication around this, it condensed.” (He means his own communication. He condensed it.)
- After the killing of Amir Locke, Frey did a press conference with interim chief Amelia Huffman. It’s an infuriating thing to watch because he starts out performative, and then a few minutes after saying how transparent he wants to be and how he wants to answer all the questions, he and Huffman just walk out because people continue to ask why Amir Locke was referred to as a “suspect” in the official police press release.
- But if he is not able to keep the police from murdering citizens sleeping in their homes, is he at least able to get them to do their job? Hell no.
He’s been bad at supporting transit, he’s been bad at keeping property taxes in check, he’s just bad at his job. Don’t rank Frey.
DeWayne Davis
DeWayne Davis spent several years as the Lead Minister at Plymouth Congregational Church, but prior to going to divinity school he worked in Washington, DC as a congressional aide. When I went to his event he talked some about this: he arrived in Washington just as the Democrats lost their congressional majority, and he thought he wouldn’t have a lot to do, but he turned out to be completely incorrect. The Republicans of that era, he noted, did still at least believe in governance, and they were able to come up with a lot of useful bills he was able to get them to cooperate on.
More recently, he co-chaired the Minneapolis Community Safety Working Group, and he talked some about that, too, how it was a large, diverse group that needed to reach consensus on the recommendations, and did, only to have the mayor ignore most of what they came up with. He clearly believes in the value of working groups like the one he served on and talked about an approach to problems that involved gathering stakeholders and getting them invested in solutions they now see as their idea. He’s extremely clear-eyed about his goals, extremely flexible in what path he’d take to get there — he clearly has plenty of ideas about good paths, but one of his biggest frustrations with Frey is his my-way-or-the-highway thinking.
The thing that particularly struck me when I met him in person: he is an extremely good listener. There are a lot of people (me included) who spend a lot of time waiting for their turn to talk; he is someone who listens, and listens with deep empathy.
I asked him if he could identify a problem in Minneapolis that he thought he could solve as mayor. He said he thought he could maybe not solve but make a significant impact on homelessness and encampments; he wants to “depopulate” the encampments rather than clearing them, by giving the service organizations enough resources to give the people in encampments better options of places to go. (Here’s his response at the DFL City Convention Q&A to a question about encampments.)
I really liked him. I think he’d be extremely effective as mayor, and would do really good stuff. He’d be my #1 pick.
Omar Fateh
Omar Fateh was elected to the State Legislature (SD 62) in 2020, defeating incumbent Jeff Hayden. Link is to my post from that year; one of the things that struck me was the comment from someone who was a delegate that year who said, “Omar Fateh must have called me personally at least a half a dozen times prior to the voting. I think I got one phone call from Jeff Hayden.” Omar Fateh’s organizing ability is honestly kind of unparalleled, at least locally, and he’s the one who probably has the best chance of defeating Frey.
He was born in the DC area to parents who had immigrated from Somalia, grew up in Virginia, and moved to Minnesota in 2015. He has worked in voter services and for MNDOT. As a legislator, his major accomplishments include the statewide minimum wage for rideshare drivers, and the North Star Promise scholarships.
I’ve seen a lot of scaremongering about him, so let me go through the stuff I’ve heard and whether I think it has any basis in reality.
- I got an e-mail from someone who had heard that Fateh was homophobic. I don’t know where this came from (assumptions about his religion and background, is my guess) but this has zero basis in fact. He is endorsed by Outfront Minnesota Action (as their second choice after DeWayne Davis) and has spoken out against homophobia and transphobia and about the responsibility of Minneapolis to protect trans people who live here.
- Various people have suggested he was involved in the Feeding Our Future fraud. He was not. Some of the fraudsters sent him campaign donations; he returned the money. In the spring of 2021, when the Minnesota Department of Education put a hold on payments to Feeding Our Future, fraud mastermind Aimee Bock called up all her political connections, and both Omar Fateh and Jacob Frey called MDE to intervene. (Genuinely they were not the only ones duped. I remember a super sympathetic TV puff piece on a local news station about one of the food sites that was later revealed to be committing fraud, about how many kids were going to go hungry if the money being held wasn’t released soon.) Intervening to remove bureaucratic obstacles is a normal constituent service and I don’t think either Omar Fateh or Jacob Frey did anything wrong there. Worth noting, Jacob Frey’s staff and appointees included three people who committed fraud, all of whom wound up taking plea deals. (None of them continued working in the roles Frey had appointed them to after being charged.)
- Back in 2022, there were allegations of vote fraud from Omar Fateh’s 2020 primary campaign. (That’s a link to my post from the time.) I took this fairly seriously at the time, but a Republican in the legislature said, “There was a lot of smoke, but no fire.” There were no further developments after 2022. Also in 2022 there was a minor scandal over some ads that Fateh paid for out of the wrong checking account, and a failure to report as a corporate donation some donated space for a campaign office. The legislative ethics committee ordered him to take remedial campaign finance training, which he did. If he’d had any ethics problems since then, I am sure I’d be hearing about them from the Frey campaign’s proxies; I’m not worried about any of this at this point.
- He won DFL endorsement, then had it stripped by the State committee. He got that endorsement fair and square; no shenanigans were involved unless by “shenanigans” you mean “he out-organized Frey by a country mile.” (The endorsement was stripped on the grounds that DeWayne Davis was incorrectly dropped after the first ballot. Which was the result of human error, and which delegates knew about at the time; the convention voted to move forward with a Omar Fateh vs. Jacob Frey ballot anyway. Frey’s supporters then walked out in an attempt to break quorum, which they failed to do. If you walk out to break quorum and fail to do it, you’ve just conceded the field to your opponent and should take the L, at that point.)
- Part of why there’s so much negative stuff swirling out there is that the Frey campaign thinks he’s the biggest threat and has deliberately tried to gin up negative coverage. You can see an example of that here (headline: “Omar Fateh’s mayoral campaign probably broke state law, judge says.” What they’re actually talking about: Fateh’s campaign may have used some of their “DFL endorsed” lit in the days after the DFL endorsement got pulled, and he did not immediately update his website. (I cannot even begin to tell you how many times I’ve seen centrist candidates not pull down their DFL Senior Caucus endorsement after the DFL as a whole endorsed someone else. Or how many times I’ve seen people leave “DFL Endorsed” on their website from the previous cycle when they didn’t get endorsed in the new race. Never seen Fox 9 report on it before, though!)
He is the left-most of the serious candidates and his list of goals includes rent control, along with a lot of urbanist stuff like 24/7 bus lanes. If you are looking for the most left-wing candidate in the race, he’s probably already your first choice, but if you’re a centrist whose first choice is Jazz Hampton, let me make a case for Omar Fateh as your third choice over Jacob Frey.
When I met him in person (at a Jews for Fateh fundraiser) I asked him the same question I asked DeWayne: is there a problem in Minneapolis that you look at and think, I can solve this. He asked if I wanted to hear about governance solution or a policy solution, and then said he’d give me one of each. For governance, he talked about his years in the legislature working mostly within divided governance to get things done. (And I will note that when the Minneapolis City Council passed the rideshare ordinance, and Lyft and Uber announced they were going to simply pull out, it was Fateh who came up with a compromise that softened the rules in the metro but applied statewide. He’s someone who will stake out a left wing position as a starting place so that when he meets people halfway, they’re meeting somewhere in the actual middle, and not way over on the right.)
The policy thing he said he thinks he could fix is an ambitious youth agenda — job programs, arts programs, a bunch of things that will get teenagers off the streets. He talked about a summer jobs program he was involved with, how he realized that it was being “promoted” only in the sense that there were flyers on a desk at the park building, and arranged for people to go door to door with information. (That’s another thing I really like about him: his skill at organizing isn’t just for getting him elected, he uses it in other ways.) At the end of the summer he talked to some of the teenagers and asked how they spent the money, expecting to hear about new gaming systems, and instead heard from multiple kids that they gave it to their mom to buy groceries and pay rent.
In order to pass rent control, he’ll need support from the City Council. This year’s City Council was progressive enough to pass a bunch of things that Frey vetoed: however, Katie Cashman is on the record as opposed to rent control, and Aurin Chowdhury is open to it but only with an exemption for new construction. Most of the leftyist leftist things that the city centrists are pearl-clutching over Omar Fateh potentially doing are things he would have to temper significantly to get through the City Council (and others are things he would have to first get through the State Legislature, he’s not even saying “we’re going to do this!” but “we’re going to advocate that the State Legislature pass a bill to let us consider doing this at some point in the future!”)
The thing that struck me the most about Omar Fateh was his ability to bring people together to work. I mean, when people say someone is an “amazing organizer” that’s kind of what they mean, and it was cool to see it in action. I will also note that when he delivered his speech at the gathering, he explicitly asked everyone to rank Jazz and DeWayne as well. I think he would be an excellent mayor and I would rank him #2.
Jazz Hampton
Jazz Hampton is a lawyer and an entrepreneur; in 2020 he created an app (TurnSignl) that lets users get an instant video-chat lawyer on their phone if they’re pulled over while driving. (You can see a recorded call demonstrating it in use here.)
I went to a Jazz meet-and-greet called “Politics at the Playground.” He noted that it’s hard for parents to participate in politics (he is himself the father of two pretty young kids) and by setting up events at parks adjacent to play areas he hoped to make it a little easier for parents to show up and learn more about his campaign. Small children who wanted to ask questions were also encouraged to do so.
The thing that struck me the most about Jazz was his positive outlook. He’s friendly in a way that says he genuinely likes people. I asked him my question about what problem he thinks he could solve, and he said “economic revitalization” and talked about improving the climate for small businesses, calling out a restaurant that had opened nearby only to almost get killed off by road construction that was supposed to take six weeks, and instead took six months. He wants to streamline regulations and inspections (I was looking through stuff about 2013 yesterday and that was a big issue in 2013 and is still an issue).
(I will note that Omar Fateh and DeWayne Davis also want to make it a better city for small businesses. In terms of problems and solutions in general the policies all three of them want have a lot in common. They all want more community mental health workers for 911 calls where they’re more appropriate than police, they all want more interventions programs to prevent crime in the first place, they all want to do something about vacant buildings owned by land speculators, etc. But as the conversation rolled along at the meet-and-greet, Jazz came back to the problems of business owners more often than the other two did.)
I think he’d be a significant improvement over Jacob Frey, and I would rank him #3.
This has been a long post, but let me sum up with another pep talk.
Jacob Frey can be beaten! Another Frey term is not inevitable. However, you (we) need to not succumb to analysis paralysis, where fail to donate to or doorknock for anyone because we are undecided between DeWayne and Omar, or between DeWayne and Jazz. We need to pick a favorite and get out there. The strength of Instant Runoff is that people who like DeWayne the most but think Omar has a better shot at winning can list them 1/2. The weakness of Instant Runoff is that it gives us the opportunity to dither over that 1/2 ranking when considering who to donate to / doorknock for. And dithering when we should be doorknocking is a free donation to Jacob Frey.
Put up a sign for your favorite. Or your top two favorites. Or make a sign with your ranking. Talk to your neighbors about how you’re voting and why you’re not ranking Frey. Volunteer — if you can’t stand doorknocking, you can go table for people at Open Streets or go chat with people who come to the next meet-and-greet or help with a fundraiser.
Jazz Hampton events
DeWayne Davis events
Omar Fateh events
(All of those links lead to Mobilize and include doorknocking, fundraisers, house parties, meet-and-greets, and opportunities like “Table for [Team] at Open Streets!”)
I have a new book coming out next June! This one is not YA; it’s a near-future thriller about an obstetrician who gets kidnapped by a cult because they want someone on site to deliver babies. You can pre-order it right now if you want.
I do not have a Patreon or Ko-Fi but instead encourage people who want to reward all my hard work to donate to fundraisers. This year I’m fundraising for YouthLink. YouthLink is a Minneapolis nonprofit that helps youth (ages 16-24) who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. (Here’s their website.) I have seen some of the work they do and been really impressed. (An early donor to the fundraiser added a comment: “YouthLink was incredible instrumental in my assistance of a friend to escape a bad family situation in Florida with little more than a computer and a state ID. Thanks to YouthLink and their knowledge of resources my friend was able to get a mailing address (which was essential in getting a debit card and formal identification documents), healthcare, hot meals, an internship at a local company, and even furniture for their new apartment.” — That is exactly the sort of thing I’m talking about!)
I set up a fundraiser with a specific goal mainly because seeing the money raised helps motivate me. (Having external motivation helps! This is a lot of work.)
https://naomikritzer.com/2025/09/18/election-2025-minneapolis-mayoral-race-the-four-contenders/
http://naomikritzer.com/?p=24148